Handling “Messages” from Jesus and Mary

October 4, 2026

Dear brothers and sisters of the Flame of Love of the Immaculate Heart of Mary Movement,

May the peace and grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, the love of the Father and the communion be with you all.

I am writing to encourage everyone to exercise great caution and discernment when speaking about visions, dreams, prophecies, or messages concerning our Movement of the Flame of Love of the Immaculate Heart of Mary or the future or the Church.

The Catechism reminds us that private revelations, even when recognized by the Church, do not belong to the deposit of faith and can never replace or contradict Sacred Scripture, Tradition, or the teachings of the Church (CCC 67).

As Scripture tells us, “Do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God” (1 John 4:1).

Rules for Discernment

When considering an alleged private revelation, we should ask:

  • Is it consistent with Scripture, Catholic doctrine, and Christian morality?
  • What spiritual fruits does it produce? Does it lead to prayer, humility, conversion, charity, peace, and greater communion with the Church—or to fear, pride, division, or condemnation?
  • Is the person receiving the message credible, psychologically and morally sound, sincere, humble, and willing to cooperate with Church authority?
  • Does the message respect legitimate Church authority and the Sacraments?
  • Does it glorify Christ, or does it place excessive attention on the messenger, secret knowledge, money, fame, or a personal following?
  • Are there signs of manipulation, deception, abuse, or a sectarian spirit?

These are not merely personal opinions. The Church has established formal norms for discerning alleged supernatural phenomena. Under the Vatican’s 2024 norms, the diocesan bishop investigates the matter in dialogue with the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, examining both positive and negative evidence, including doctrinal consistency, the credibility and condition of those involved, and the fruits produced.

It is also important to understand that a Nihil obstat does not declare that an apparition or revelation is certainly supernatural, nor does it make the phenomenon an object of faith. It indicates that, after discernment, no elements contrary to faith or morals have been found and that positive spiritual fruits may be recognized.

Let us therefore not accept every vision, prophecy, dream, or extraordinary message simply because it is presented as being from God. Test everything and hold fast to what is good (1 Thessalonians 5:21). When there is uncertainty, let us choose prayer, humility, patience, and trust rather than fear, speculation, or division.

Our faith is founded not on private revelations or predictions about the future, but on Jesus Christ, His Gospel, His Sacraments, and His Church. Whatever is truly from God will lead us closer to Christ and toward greater faith, charity, unity, holiness, and peace.

Addressing Unapproved Messages, “Mystics,” and Cenacle Discipline

In recent times, we have seen a flood of private writings, self-proclaimed mystics, and individuals claiming to receive direct locutions or visions. Some even assert that they answer exclusively to Jesus and Mary, placing themselves beyond the review or guidance of legitimate Church authority. This attitude is contrary to the spirit of true humility and Catholic obedience.

To maintain the spiritual purity, peace, and order of our Flame of Love cenacles, please observe the following guidelines:

  1. Keep Private Messages Out of Cenacles: No one should come to a cenacle sharing personal messages or claiming, “Jesus said this to me last night” or “Mary said that.” Cenacles are dedicated to prayer, the Rosary, the Flame of Love Movement prayers, and approved Church teachings—not the promotion or dissemination of unapproved private revelations.
  2. The Requirement of Spiritual Direction: If an individual believes they are receiving private messages, they must be under proper spiritual direction with a qualified Catholic priest. However, even if someone is under spiritual direction, personal messages must not be brought into or shared within our cenacles.
  3. Remember the Three Possible Sources: As recorded in the Spiritual Diary of Elizabeth Kindelmann, interior locutions and messages can originate from three distinct sources:
    • Divine Origin: Coming truly from God, producing humility, obedience, peace, and virtuous fruits.
    • Human Origin: Coming from the person’s own imagination, emotional state, or psychological desires.
    • Demonic Origin: Coming from the enemy, which often disguises itself under the appearance of piety or urgency, but ultimately fosters spiritual pride, subtle disobedience, fear, or division.

Even Elizabeth Kindelmann underwent rigorous testing and guidance under her spiritual directors to discern the true source of her experiences. If Elizabeth herself submitted everything to Church authority and spiritual direction, no one today can claim exemption from such discernment.

Let us remain vigilant, rooted in the Sacraments, and focused on the core mission of the Flame of Love: passing the flame from heart to heart through prayer, sacrifice, and deep unity with the Holy Catholic Church.

May God bless you and the Blessed Mother of the Flame of Love brings us always closer to Jesus and one another.

Fr. Jorge